•  
  •  
 

Title

Gnesioi filoi: the Search for George Syncellus’ and Theophanes the Confessor’s Own Words, and the Authorship of Their Oeuvre

Abstract

In a nutshell: 1. I believe that Ekloge Chronographias of George Syncellus and Chronographia of Theophanes the Confessor should be treated as a single project, undertaken in turn by two authors; 2. There are important stylistic differences between the two parts, noticeable in the fragments, in which the authors deliver some editorial remarks or disclose their personal opinions; from a wider selection of such phrases, references to the past or future such as ‘as I have mentioned/as I said/as have been said/as we demonstrated above, etc.’, being diverse and individual, are especially helpful. 3. This observation is of great use not only for the texts analysed here, it may be used to confirm authorship of many other texts. 4. As for George and Theophanes, the TLG search of such structures in all extant classical Greek and Byzantine output confirms the statement nr 1, with clauses like ὡς προέφην/καθὼς καὶ προέφην/ὡς προέφημεν/καθὼς προέφημεν both rare in the whole preserved corpus, and relatively often used by the author of Chronographia. The style of the proemium of Chronographia fits the rest of the work and differs from Ekloge Chronographias. 5. Precise analysis of a wider group of similar clauses shows that Ekloge Chronographias and Chronographia were written by two different authors; Chronographia was created by one author, distinctive and independent, no matter how reproductive at the same time he was. I see no convincing arguments not to call this author Theophanes. Some later and partial editiorial interventions to Chronographia, conceivable (rubrics?) and in some instances even certain, do not challenge this view. 6. Only a few entries from the initial parts of Chronographia fit more the George’s work; their style and content bear much more similarities with Ekloge (in AM 5796, 5814, 5818, 5827, 5828). These paragraphs, George’s aphormai, probably in form of loose notes, were inserted to Chronographia by its author the same way as he used his sources for the subsequent parts; they did not reach beyond the times of Constantine I. 7. I do not dismiss the message of the proemium to the Chronographia as it is much more credible than the discussion, sometimes hypercritical, on the vitae and the scraps of the Confessor’s biography. I see no reason not to believe that the idea established and developed by George was then taken over by his friend; the differences result from the independent work of the former and then of the latter, presumably with only rudimentary guidance at the beginning. 8. The ‘genuine friendship’, the crucial relation between the two authors is still the most useful key to understand the history of the tripartita – therefore, I analyse it in the final part of the paper.

Keywords

Theophanes Confessor, George Syncellus, Georgios Synkellos, Byzantine chronography, Chronographia, Ekloge chronographias, gnesios filos, friendship, historia tripartita, TLG, world chronicles, aphormai, prophemi, hos proephen, kathos kai proephen, hos proephemen

References

Thesaurus Linguae Graecae: A Digital Library of Greek Literature, University of California (http://www.tlg.uci.edu).

Andrew of Crete, In exaltationem venerandae crucis [= or. XI], PG 97.

Andrew of Crete, Homilia in exaltatione s. crucis, ed. M. de Groote, HTR 100, 2007, p. 443–487.

Andrew of Crete, In s. Patapium, [in:] PG 97, col. 1206–1221[1254].

The Chronicle of Theophanes Confessor: Byzantine and Near Eastern History AD 284–813, trans. with introd. and comm. C. Mango, R. Scott, with assist. of G. Greatrex, Oxford 1997.

The Chronography of George Synkellos: A Byzantine Chronicle of Universal History from the Creation, trans. with introd. and notes W. Adler, P. Tuffin, Oxford 2002.

Le commentaire de Theodore de Mopsueste sur les Psaumes (I–LXXX), ed. R. Devreesse, Citta del Vaticano 1939.

Concilium Quinisextum, ed. H. Ohme, Turnhout 2006.

Eusebius Werke, vol. V, Die Chronik aus der Armenischen ubersetzt, ed. J. Karst, Leipzig 1911.

Evagrius of Pontus, Spirituales sententiae per alphabetum dipositae, [in:] Gnomica, rec. A. Elter, vol. I, Lipsiae 1892.

Evagrius Scholasticus, ed. J. Bidez, L. Parmentier, London 1898.

Georges Pachymeres, Relations Historiques, VI, 24, ed. A. Failler, trans. V. Laurent, vol. I, Paris 1984.

Georgii Syncelli Ecloga chronographica, ed. A. A. Mosshammer, Leipzig 1984.

Joseph Flavius, Antiquitates iudaicae, ed. B. Niese.

Menandri sententiae, 471, ed. S. Jäkel, Leipzig 1964.

Michael Syncellus, Encomium martyrum XLII Amoriensum (versio Γ), [in:] Сказания о 42 Амо-рийских мучениках и церковная служба им, ed. В. ВАСИЛЬЕВСКИЙ, П. НИКИТИН, Санкт-Петербург 1905.

Nicephorus Gregoras, Historia Romana, ed. I. Bekker, L. Schopen, vol. I, Bonnae 1829; vol. II, 1830; vol. III, 1855.

Palladio, La storia Lausiaca, ed. G. J. M. Bartelink, Verona 1974.

Papyri Graecae magicae. Die griechischen Zauberpapyri, vol. II, ed. K. Preisendanz & A. Henrichs, 2Stutgardiae 1974.

Passio magni martyris Artemii, [in:] Die Schriften des Johannes von Damaskos, vol. V, ed. P. B. Kotter, Berlin–New York 1988.

Philonis Alexandrini opera quae supersunt, rec. L. Cohn, vol. V, Berlin 1906.

Pseudo-Macarius the Egyptian, [in:] Die 50 geistlichen Homilien des Makarios, ed. H. Dörries, E. Klostermann, M. Krüger, Berlin 1964.

Theodori Studitae Epistulae, rec. G. Fatouros, vol. II, Berolini–Novi Eboraci 1992.

Theophanis Chronographia, rec. C. G. de Boor, vol. I, Lipsić 1883.

Le version breve des Relations Historiques de Georges Pachymeres, VI, 24, ed. A. Failler, vol. I, Paris 2001.

Vita Aesopi Westermanniana (recensio 2), [in:] Aesopica, ed. B. E. Perry, vol. I, Urbana 1952.

Vita et miracula sancti Demetrii, [in:] P. Lemerle, Les plus anciens recueils des miracles de saint Demetrius et la penetration des Slaves dans les Balkans, vol. I, Paris 1979.

Adler W., Eusebius’ Critique of Africanus, [in:] Julius Africanus und die christliche Weltchronik. Julius Africanus und die christliche Weltchronistik, ed. M. Wallraff, Berlin–New York 2006, p. 148–157.

Afinogenov D., The History of Justinian and Leo, [in:] La Crimee entre Byzance et le Khaganat Khazare, ed. C. Zuckerman, Paris 2006 (CHCB Monographies, 25), p. 181–200.

Afinogenov D., The Source of Theophanes’ Chronography and Nikephoros’ Breviarium for the years 685–717, XB 4, 2005, p. 3–14.

Beck H.-G., Byzantinisches Gefolgschaftswesen, München 1965.

de Boor C., Ueber die kritischen Hulfsmittel zu einer Ausgabe des Theophanes, [in:] Theophanis Chronographia, vol. II, Lipsiae 1885, p. 374–399.

Brandes W., Pejorative Phantomnamen im 8. Jahrhundert. Ein Beitrag zur Quellenkritik des Theophanes und deren Konsequenzen fur die historische Forschung, [in:] Zwischen Polis, Provinz und Peripherie. Beitrage zur byzantinischen Geschichte und Kultur, hrsg. L. M. Hoffmann (Mainzer Veröffentlichungen zur Byzantinistik 17), Wiesbaden 2005, p. 93–125.

Brubaker L., Haldon J., Byzantium in the Iconoclast Era (c. 680–850): The Sources – an Annotated Survey, Aldershot 2001.

Burgess R. W., Apologetic and Chronography: The Antecendents of Julius Africanus, [in:] Julius Africanus und die christliche Weltchronik. Julius Africanus und die christliche Weltchronistik, ed. M. Wallraff, Berlin–New York 2006, p. 17–42.

Dumbarton Oaks Hagiography Database

Ferber J., Theophanes’ Account of the Reign of Heraclius, [in:] Byzantine Papers: Proceedings of the First Australian Byzantine Studies Conference, Canberra, 17–19 May 1978, ed. E. Jeffreys, M. Jeffreys, A. Moffatt, Canberra 1981, p. 32–42.

Howard-Johnston J. D., Witnesses to a World Crisis: Historians and Histories of the Middle East in the Seventh Century, Oxford 2010.

Hunger H., Die Hochsprachliche profane Literatur der Byzantiner, vol. I, München 1978.

Karpozēlos A., Byzantinoi historikoi kai chronographoi, vol. II, 8os–10os ai., Athens 2002.

Kazhdan A., History of Byzantine literature (650–850), Athens 1999.

Kompa A., Zbieżność losow a zbieżność narracji. O strukturze i autorstwie „Chronografii” Teofanesa, [in:] Średniowieczna wizja świata. Jedność czy rożnorodność (idee i teksty) – III Kongres Mediewistow Polskich, Polska i Europa w średniowieczu. Przemiany strukturalne. Łodź 22–24 września 2008, ed. M. J. Leszka, T. Wolińska, Łódź 2009, p. 141–161.

Kompa A., In search of Syncellus’ and Theophanes’ own words: the authorship of the Chronographia revisited, TM 19, 2015 (= Studies in Theophanes, ed. M. Jankowiak, F. Montinaro, Paris 2015), p. 73–92.

Lampsides O., Ephraem Aenii Historia chronica, Athens 1990.

Leszka M. J., Leon V i chan Krum w świetle fragmentu Chronografii (AM 6305) Teofanesa Wyznawcy, PNH 6, 2007, p. 109–117.

Ljubarskij J., Concerning the Literary Technique of Theophanes the Confessor, Bsl 61, 1995, p. 317–322.

Mango C., The Availability of Books in the Byzantine Empire, A. D. 750–850, [in:] Byzantine Books and Bookmen, ed. C. Mango, I. Ševčenko, Washington 1975, p. 29–45.

Mango C., Who Wrote the Chronicle of Theophanes?, ЗРВИ 18, 1978, p. 9–17.

Mosshammer A., The Christian Era of Julius Africanus with an Excursus on Olympiad Chronology, [in:] [in:] Julius Africanus und die christliche Weltchronik. Julius Africanus und die christliche Weltchronistik, ed. M. Wallraff, Berlin–New York 2006, p. 83–112.

Olster D., Syriac Sources, Greek Sources, and Theophanes Lost Year, BF 19, 1993, p. 218–228.

Pigulevskaja N., Theophanes’ Chronographia and the Syrian Chronicles, JÖBG 16, 1967, p. 55–60.

Proudfoot A. S., The Sources of Theophanes for the Heraclian Dynasty, B 44, 1974, p. 367–439.

Řecko-staroslověnsky index, vol. I, Prolegomena. Tabellae synopticae monumentorum slavicorum A–G, ed. E. Bláhová, Praha 2014.

Rochow I., Byzanz im 8. Jahrhundert in der Sicht des Theophanes. Quellenkritisch-historischer Kommentar zu den Jahren 715–813, Berlin 1991.

Rochow I., Malalas bei Theophanes, K 65, 1983, p. 459–474.

Scott R., “The Events of Every Year, Arranged without Confusion”: Justinian and Others in the Chronicle of Theophanes Confessor, [in:] L’ecriture de la memoire. La litterarite de l’historiographie, ed. P. Odorico, P. A. Agapitos, M. Hinterberger, Paris 2006, p. 49–65.

Scott R., Byzantine Chronicles, MChr 6, 2009, p. 31–57.

Scott R., From Propaganda to History to Literature: the Byzantine Stories of Theodosius’ Apple and Marcian’s Eagles, [in:] History as Literature in Byzantium, ed. R. Macrides, Aldershot 2010, p. 122–127.

Scott R., Writing the Reign of Justinian: Malalas versus Theophanes, [in:] The Sixth Century: End or Beginning, ed. P. Allen, E. Jeffreys, Brisbane 1996, p. 21–34.

Ševčenko I., The Search for the Past in Byzantium around the Year 800, DOP 46, 1992, p. 287–289.

Sophoulis P., Byzantium and Bulgaria, 775–831, Leiden 2012.

Speck P., Das geteilte Dossier. Beobachtungen zu den Nachrichten uber die Regierung des Kaiser Herakleios und seine Sohne bei Theophanes und Nikephoros, Bonn 1988.

Speck P., Kaiser Leon III., die Geschichtswerke des Nikephoros und des Theophanes und der Liber pontificalis, vol. I, Bonn 2002 (PB 19).

Speck P., Der ‘zweite’ Theophanes. Eine These zur Chronographie des Theophanes, [in:] Poikila Byzantina, vol. XIII, Varia V, Bonn 1994, p. 431–483.

Studies in Theophanes, ed. M. JANKOWIAK, F. MONTINARO, Paris 2015 (= TM 19).

Thesaurus Linguae Graecae Canon of Greek Authors and Works, ed. L. Berkowitz and K. A. Squitier, Oxford 1990 (& on-line version, ed. M. Pantelia).

Thesaurus Theophanis Confessoris, ed. B. Coulie, P. Yannopoulos, Turnhout 1998.

Totomahoba A.-M., A Lost Byzantine Chronicle in Slavic Translation, SCer 1, 2011, p. 191–204.

Whitby L. M., The Great Chronographer and Theophanes, BMGS 8, 1982 / 1983, p. 1–20.

Whitby L. M., Theophanes’ Chronicle Source for the Reigns of Justin II, Tiberius and Maurice (A. D. 565–602), B 53, 1983, p. 312–345.

Wilson N. G., A Manuscript of Theophanes in Oxford, DOP 26, 1972, p. 358.

Yannopoulos P., „Comme le dit Georges le Syncelle ou, je pense, Theophane”, B 74, 2004, p. 139–146.

Yannopoulos P., Theophane de Sigriani le Confesseur (759–818). Un heros orthodoxe du second iconoclasme, Bruxelles 2013.

Yannopoulos P., Les vicissitudes historiques de la Chronique the Theophane, B 70, 2000, p. 527–553.

КУЗЕНКОВ П., Хронография Георгия Синкелла – Феофана Исповедника: хронологический аспект, [in:] ΚΑΝΙΣΚΙΟΝ: Юбилейный сборник в честь 60-летия проф. Игоря Сергеевича Чичурова, ed. М. В. ГРАЦИАНСКИЙ, П. В. КУЗЕНКОВ, Москва 2006, p. 156–168.

ЛЮБАРСКИЙ Я. Н., Феофан Исповедник и источники его «Хронографии»: (К вопросу о методах их освоения), BB 45, 1984, p. 72–86.

TOTOMAHOBA A.-M., Славянската версия на Хрониката на Георги Синкел, София 2008.

ЧИЧУРОВ И. С., Феофан – компилятор Феофилакта Симокатты, АДСВ 10, 1973, p. 203–206.

ЧИЧУРОВ И. С., Феофан Исповедник – компилятор Прокопия, BB 37, 1976, p. 62–73.

ЧИЧУРОВ И. С., Феофан Исповедник – публикатор, редактор, автор? (В связи со статьей К. Манго), BB 42, 1981, p. 78–87.

First Page

155

Last Page

230

Language

eng

Share

COinS