The article examines the application and exploration of Ulster dialects in the work of two poets of Northern Irish Protestant background, Tom Paulin and Michael Longley. It depicts Paulin's attitude to the past and the present of their community of origin, the former positive and the latter negative, which is responsible for the ambiguities in his use of and his comments on the local speech. Both poets employ the vernacular to refer to their immediate context, i.e. the conflict in Ulster, and in this respect linguistic difference comes to be associated with violence. Yet another vital element of their exploration of the dialect is its link to their origins, home and the intimacy it evokes, which offers a contrary perspective on the issue of languages and makes their approach equivocal. This context in Paulin's poetry is further enriched with allusions to or open discussion of the United Irishmen ideal and the international Protestant experience, and with his reworking of ancient Greek myth and tragedy, while in Longley's poetry it is set in the framework of "translations" from Homer which, strangely enough, transport the reader to contemporary Ireland. While Longley in his comments (interviews and autobiographical writings) relates the dialect to his personal experience, Paulin (in his essays and in interviews) seems to situate it in a vaster network of social and political concepts that he has developed in connection with language, which in Ireland has never seemed a neutral phenomenon detached from historical and political implications. Longley's use of local speech is seldom discussed by critics; Paulin's, on the contrary, has stirred diverse reactions and controversies. The article investigates some of these critical views chiefly concerned with the alleged artificiality of his use of local words and with his politicizing the dialects. Performing the analysis of his poems and essays, the article argues for Paulin's "consistency in inconsistency," i.e. the fact that his application of dialectal words reflects his love-hate attitude to his community of origin, and that in the clash of two realities, of the conflict and of home, his stance and literary practice is not far from Longley's, which has been regarded as quite neutral as one can infer from the lack of critical controversy about it. The voices of the two poets and their use of local speech provide a crucial insight into the Northern Irish reality with all its intricacy and paradox.
Arts and Humanities | Social and Behavioral Sciences
Andrews, Elmer ed. Contemporary Irish Poetry: A Collection of Critical Essays. London: Macmillan 1992.
Andrews, Elmer ed. "Tom Paulin: Underground Resistance Fighter." Poetry in Contemporary Irish Literature. Ed. Michael Kenneally. Gerrards Cross: Colin Smythe 1995: 329-43.
Corcoran, Neil. "Tom Paulin." The Oxford Companion to Twentieth-Century Poetry in English. Ed. Ian Hamilton. Oxford: Oxford University Press 1994: 412-13.
Craig, Patricia. "History and Its Retrieval in Contemporary Northern Irish Poetry: Paulin Montague and Others." Contemporary Irish Poetry: A Collection of Critical Essays. Ed. Elmer Andrews. London: Macmillan 1992: 107-23.
Craig, Patricia. "Reflexes and Reflections." Rev. of Ireland and the English Crisis by Tom Paulin. Times Literary Supplement 19 Apr. 1985.
Dawe, Gerald. "Poems of a Northern Protest-ant." Rev. of Liberty Tree by Tom Paulin. ILS (1984): 29.
Heaney, Seamus. "Introduction." Beowulf. Trans. Seamus Heaney. London: Faber 1999: ix-xxx.
Johnstone, Robert. "Guldering Unselfconsciously." Rev. of Field Day Pamphlets Nos. 1 to 3 by Tom Paulin Seamus Heaney and Seamus Deane. Honest Ulsterman 75 (May 1984): 85-91.
Johnstone, Robert. "Harmonics between Electrified Fences." Rev. of Gorse Fires by Michael Longley. Honest Ulsterman 92 (1991): 78-82.
Longley, Michael. Gorse Fires. London: Secker & Warburg 1991.
Longley, Michael. Poems 1963-1983. Dublin: Gallery 1985.
Longley, Michael. The Ghost Orchid. London: Cape Poetry 1995.
Longley, Michael. The Weather in Japan. London: Cape Poetry 2000.
Longley, Michael. Tuppenny Stung: Autobiographical Chapters. Belfast: Lagan 1994.
Longley, Michael. Interview by Sarah Broom. Metre 4 (1998): 17-26.
Longley, Michael. Interview by Jerzy Jarniewicz and Piotr Sommer. "Porządnie skrojony płatek śniegu." Literatura na Świecie 4-5 (2000): 251-67.
Longley, Michael. Interview by Dillon Johnston. "Q. & A.: Michael Longley." ILS (1986): 20-22.
Longley, Michael. Interview. "The Longley Tapes." Honest Ulsterman 78 (1985): 13-31.
McDonald, Peter. "History and Poetry: Derek Mahon and Tom Paulin." Contemporary Irish Poetry: A Collection of Critical Essays. Ed. Elmer Andrews. London: Macmillan 1992: 86-106.
Paulin, Tom. A New Look at the Language Question. Derry: Field Day Theatre Company 1983.
Paulin, Tom. Fivemiletown. London: Faber 1987.
Paulin, Tom. Ireland and the English Crisis. Newcastle-upon-Tyne: Bloodaxe 1984.
Paulin, Tom. Liberty Tree. London: Faber 1983.
Paulin, Tom. Minotaur: Poetry and the Nation State. Cambridge MA: Harvard University Press 1992.
Paulin, Tom. Seize the Fire London: Faber and Faber 1990.
Paulin, Tom. The Hillsborough Script: A Dramatic Satire. London: Faber 1987.
Paulin, Tom. The Riot Act. London: Faber 1985.
Paulin, Tom. The Strange Museum. London: Faber 1980.
Paulin, Tom. The Wind Dog. London: Faber 1999.
Paulin, Tom. Walking a Line. London: Faber 1994.
Paulin, Tom. Interview by Eamonn Hughes. "Q. & A. with Tom Paulin." ILS (1988): 31-32.
Watson, George. "An Uncomfortable Spikey Poet." Rev. of Fivemile-town by Tom Paulin. ILS (1988): 33.
Wheatley, David. "Billycan Campfire Tinniness." Rev. of The Wind Dog by Tom Paulin. ILS (2000): 7.
Wills, Clair. Improprieties: Politics and Sexuality in Northern Irish Poetry. Oxford: Clarendon Press 1993.